Court Acquits Pura Luka Vega, But Questions Remain About Respect and Expression

Drag performer Pura Luka Vega, whose real name is Amadeus Fernando Pagente, has been acquitted by the Manila Regional Trial Court in connection to a controversial performance that many saw as mocking religious beliefs. The act, which involved dressing as Jesus Christ and dancing to a remix of the Lord’s Prayer (“Ama Namin”), sparked outrage across the country, especially among Catholics who consider the prayer sacred.

The case was filed by the religious group Hijos Del Nazareno, which took offense at Vega’s performance in July 2023. They described the act as “blasphemous” and “deeply disrespectful.” The group argued that the portrayal went beyond performance art and crossed into a clear act of irreverence, especially since it was shared publicly online.

In its ruling dated June 10, Judge Czarina Samonte-Villanueva of Manila RTC Branch 184 acquitted Vega, stating that the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt under Article 201 of the Revised Penal Code, in relation to the Cybercrime Prevention Act.

While the court ultimately cleared Vega of criminal charges, it made a pointed remark about the need to be mindful of cultural and religious contexts, especially in performances shared on social media. The ruling emphasized that this reminder was not about curbing one’s rights but about being considerate of the broader community.

The controversy started when Vega appeared in a viral video wearing a golden crown and robes resembling religious imagery while dancing to an upbeat remix of the “Ama Namin.” The video was met with mixed reactions, but many, particularly people of faith, felt insulted. For them, the performance was not just edgy or creative; it was offensive.

Vega was arrested in October 2023 and spent three days in detention before posting bail. They were also declared persona non grata in several cities including Manila, Cebu, and General Santos. Another case, filed by the Philippines for Jesus Movement, remains pending.

Following the acquittal, Vega thanked supporters online, saying, “One more case left. Just fight.” But for many observers, the issue is not just legal, it’s moral. Yes, freedom of expression matters. But respect for sacred beliefs should never be treated as optional in the name of art.